A Bertram Chandler
Article - Tarzan and the Myth-Makers
Articles
All Aboard For Armageddon
Anjin-sama and the Admiral Revisited
Appreciation of Jack Vance
Around the World in 23,741 Days
Australian S. F. Fans
Better a Bad Review Than None At All - Perhaps
Cook's Tour of Convenience Food Country
Curse of Ned Kelly
Death of a Thousand Cuts
Durable Desperadoes
Ellison Show
Gold is Where You Find It
Grimes-San and the Naked Lady
Grimesish Grumberlings
Heard But Not Seen
If This is Tokyo it Must Be Friday
International SF
Japanese Branch of the SF Family
John Grimes - Autobiographical Notes
John W. Campbell
Kelly Country Foreward
Late (Introduction)
Lost In Space And Time Without (Alas!) Ferdinand Feghoot
Misplaced Apostrophe and Other Crimes
My Life and Grimes
My Life and Grimes
My Life and Grimes'
Notes on the Battle of Kiel
Nothing Like a Good Whinge
Nudism In Fiction
Pet Corns
Pig Island Revisited
Present Shock
Quest for Fire
Question on the Fate of Skylab
Rally Round the Flag, Boys
Road to Gor
Round Up the Usual Suspects...
Running Off The Rim
Russia and The Writer
Sea and Science Fiction
Square On the Hypotenuse
Still Running the Rim
Susan Wood - A Tribute
Tarzan and the Myth-Makers
Times Ain't What They Were - But Were They Ever?
To Run the Rim
To Run the Rim
Ultimate Blimp
Up, Up and Away
Where Have All the Pigs Gone?
Writing Abroad: Australia
You Could Always Look at the Pictures
Fanzine Fiction
Reviews
Letters
Poems
Interview
The Rim of Space on Audio
Blackstone Audio have release
The Rim of Space
on Audio as part of
A Galaxy Trilogy VOL. 4
Home
Bibliography
Writing
Support
Contact
Tarzan and the Myth-Makers
To begin with, I am not, repeat not, an Edgar Rice Burroughs fan.
I used to be, once, one World War, two marriages and many, many watery miles ago. Recently, however, I have tried to read an occasional current reprint of the Tarzan and Martian novels, but they have just failed to ring any kind of bell insofar as I am concerned. They are not good writing, and they are not even good science fiction. (If you are very lucky, now and again you get both in the same parcel.)
But…
But the ones that I read so many (too many?) years ago stick in the memory. If it hadn’t been for a novel of mine - THE ALTERNATE MARTIANS – I should never have been asked to write this article. (
My
title, by the way, was THE WORLDS OF THE DREAMERS but, titlewise Ace Books always know best.) The story, such as it was, was yet another variation on the Alternate Universe theme. The basic idea was that various authors - Wells, Burroughs and Stapledon - have written, so to speak, from memory and have described a Red Planet that bears little or no relationship to the Mars of
this
Universe. My Mars, such as it was, was a most peculiar combination of the Mars of Mr. Wells (THE WAR OF THE WORLDS) and the Mars of Mr. Burroughs.
It must be over forty years ago since I read A PRINCESS OF MARS. Even so, I did have to subject my memory to undue strain to recall the names of the major characters John Carter, Dejah Thoris and Tan Tarkas. (What I did to them was something horrid, but my dreams have been unplagued by Martian swordsmen - white, green, red, yellow or black.)
So much for John Carter and his cobbers. It is a great pity, however, that he, compared to Tarzan, has such a small following. The blame for this, to
a certain extent, rests with Hollywood. Don’t you wish, don’t we all wish that there had been a long, long series of Martian films, as there has been (and still is) a long, long series of Tarzan films?
After a lapse of many a year I saw a Tarzan film recently. It wasn’t intentional on my part; it was merely that it was the minor half of a double feature. (The main item on the programme was George Pal’s ATLANTIS, so bad that it was
good
...) That film - the Tarzan one - annoyed me. Tarzan, as I recall him, was already quite well educated when he first met Jane Porter. (As a result of an odd combination of circumstances he could read and write English but could speak only French…) The muscle-bound lout on the screen, however, was capable of no more than simian grunts. I couldn’t help wondering how Jane put up with him. (Don’t lets drag Connie Chatterley into this.)
Yes, most of the screen Tarzans have been a sorry lot. Even so, the word “Tarzan” has become part of the English (at least) language. Whether or not Burroughs could write (but tastes change, and Burroughs must have been a superb storyteller for his characters to have lived so long in the memory) he has made his enduring contribution to the mythology of our time. Tarzan stands among the immortals.
And how, dare one ask, does he get along with Sherlock Holmes, Dr. Jekyll and Mr. Hyde. Lady Chatterley, and that recent arrival, Commander James Bond?
Originally Published in The E.R.B. Digest No: 1 - Mar 1967